urban planning

This old dog only knows one trick

The inability to shift transport investment away from roads is a concern.

We cannot build our way out of congestion. Why is it so hard to break this cycle despite all the evidence to the contrary? The transport investment in 2020 has not changed. Most of the money will be spent on roads.

“If you only have a hammer, you tend to see every problem as a nail.”

Abraham Maslow

Success! You’re on the list.

58% of Australians (HILDA study) travel just 10 km (or less) to work but the journey can take 70 minutes. Travel time to work for Canberrans in recent years has increased by 64%. Many could easily ride 10 km in under 70 minutes. Electric bikes would make this distance seem trivial. So why is the conclusion to congestion that we need to spend more on roads?

In ever denser cities the measure for transport is how much space a commuter takes up: the less the better. A car and driver need about six square metres of space. Compare that to a bus that can take dozens of people, and light rail that can take hundreds. Both replace cars. Bikes provide health and lifestyle benefits as well. It seems obvious that active travel is the far better option. Bike paths are much cheaper to build than roads. For a cash-strapped government, the decision to build bike paths should be an easy one.

Photo by Burst on
Photo by Burst on

The response of Minister Steel is repetitive, more roads.

“Mr Steel said a number of current and recent duplication projects since the survey was completed will lower travel times, including the Cotter Road duplication, Ashley Drive duplication, stage one of Gundaroo Drive duplication, Horse Park Drive duplication and Coppins Crossing Road duplication.

Mr Steel also expects the ACT Government’s new road projects will also improve Canberrans’ commute times, including the new 6.4-kilometre corridor connecting Gungahlin and Belconnen duplication, which includes new on-road cycle lanes between Ginninderra Drive and the Barton Highway.

The Government also has plans for the duplication of Athlon Drive to add more lanes in each direction, replacing the bottleneck intersection on the Monaro Highway, as well upgrade intersections on Southern Cross Drive and Starke Street, Belconnen Way and Springvale Drive, Kent Street and Novar Street, and Launceston Street and Irving Street.”

It’s taking longer for Canberrans to get to work, according to new data, The RiotACT, 30 July 2019, accessed 3 Aug 2020

There is an alternative: build bike infrastructure before the roads choke. With more cars, the roads will always be congested, no matter how much is spent. Why should we repeat the mistakes of other cities around the world? They have learnt that bikes are better.

Photo by Nancy Guth on
Photo by Nancy Guth on

One reply on “This old dog only knows one trick”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s